e-limbo, e-zine de informacion y analasis de modos de vida actual
 
29.06.2017 / Sesión no Iniciada 
_Cultura

 _enviar articulo

e-mail emisor
e-mail receptor
Ayúdanos a evitar contactos automáticos
Anti Spam
Texto
 

En estos tiempos de hipercomunicación bastaría la invitación de enviar a un amigo cualquiera de los textos que consideres interesantes algo redundante: demasiada comunicación, demasiados textos y , en general, demasiado de todo.
Es posible que estemos de acuerdo... pero cuando encuentras algo interesante en cualquier sitio, la red, la calle, tu casa, o un lugar escondido y remoto, compartirlo no sólo es un acto (acción, hecho) de amistad o altruismo, también es una manera de ahorrar tiempo a los demás (y de que te lo ahorren a ti (si eres afortunado) a costa del tiempo que tu has podido derrochar (emplear) y el gustazo de mostrar que estuviste ahí (o donde fuera ) un poco antes (el tiempo ya no es más el que era).
Comparte con tus conocidos aquello que encuentras, es evolución.
The fine art of revenge
23-02-06 Suggested by: Jack of all Trades 

 
A legal scholar says that "eye for an eye" justice is a lot more humane than you think.

by Laura Miller



"Eye for an Eye"

By William Ian Miller

Cambridge University Press
266 pages
Nonfiction
When William Ian Miller, professor of law at the University of Michigan Law School, came to the phone to talk about his new book, "Eye for an Eye," he was, he confessed, "wired." "I've been talking to my students about the Icelandic sagas!" he said. Miller -- known in literary circles for such provocative, unclassifiable books as "The Anatomy of Disgust" and Salon favorite "The Mystery of Courage" -- cut his scholarly teeth on the sagas, and he thinks we modern types don't give the harsh but heroic societies that produced them enough respect. "Eye for an Eye" describes how justice worked in Medieval Iceland and England, and in the biblical world that formulated the most familiar version of the law of the "talion." It's defined by the American Heritage Dictionary as "a punishment identical to the offense."

"Eye for an Eye" offers a closer look at "talionic" societies -- also known as honor- or revenge-based cultures. It features such strange artifacts as a price list from 7th century England dictating in great detail the number of shillings owed to a person suffering various injuries, from a broken arm to a lost toenail. (Did you know that the little finger was worth more than the index finger? As Miller, who mangled his own pinkie while playing with his son, found out, it's more crucial to maintaining a firm grip.) Or, rather, the compensation laws of King Aethelberht might seem bizarre until you realize that contemporary insurance companies probably have the same sort of lists. And contrary to what we tell ourselves, honor-based societies, Miller argues, often placed a higher value on human lives and human bodies than we do.

Miller insists that underneath our sophisticated modern rationalizations, we still harbor talionic beliefs that make us uneasy when wrongdoers don't pay for their crimes in exact proportion to the harm they cause. That's why, he says, we like stories about characters who even up the score with their enemies -- not just vigilante action films, but comedies in which, say, the bullied nerd triumphs in the end. That's why we're fascinated by revenge.

Your book argues that we often use the term "eye for an eye" to describe a harsh kind of justice from the past. But talionic societies could be said to put a higher value on human life and the human body than we do. They were much more committed to finding the exact worth of body parts and lives. So, let's say you poke out my eye...


Then, instantly, my eye becomes yours. To get the value exactly right, we say an eye is worth an eye. You have a right to my eye. Now you can say to me, "I'm going to take your eye." Then I'm going to say, "Hey, what would you be willing to accept instead?" It becomes an initial bargaining position.

If you want victims to be more highly valued and you want real, adequate compensation, this is how to do it. Now if I offer you what some lousy insurance company says your eye is worth -- say, $100,000 -- you'll say, "No way! I would never have let you take my eye for that." Instead, you can be sure I'll put the same value on not losing my eye that you would have put on yours, and I will pay you that amount to keep my own eye. How about $5 million? Let's start there. And we'll bargain it out.

Of course there was no insurance in those societies. We like to think that life was cheap in those cultures, but the problem was that it was so expensive they couldn't get anything done. Life is cheap with us, despite all our talk about how we can't have capital punishment because human life is too valuable. Do you know there are these signs up on the Michigan highways that say, "Kill a worker, pay $7,500"?

Is that supposed to warn you to be careful not to hit a highway worker with your car?

Yes, because not only are you going to go to prison, but you'll pay a little fine. But everyone who drives by and reads it sees it as an insult. Seventy-five hundred for a highway worker! "Hey, I've got $7,500, let's knock one off!"

When people compare modern ideas of justice with the old idea of "eye for an eye," they often talk about the difference between justice and revenge.

There is no difference. The literature on punishment and retribution, the philosophical and legal literature, doesn't understand revenge. They talk about revenge as going postal, the lawless, crazed overvaluation of your own harm. But if you look at real honor cultures and real revenge cultures, they were measurers and proportionalists to the extreme. What they would call revenge is simply paying back exactly what was owed. No more, no less.

The law of the talion was not a law issued by a government to regulate criminal matters. It was tort law, a compensation principle dictating how much private party A owes private party B for the harm A did to B.

The rule of "eye for an eye" originated before there were ready money substances. There were things that worked as money, like grain and cows, but I argue that the dominate money substance in most settings was humans themselves, or parts of humans. You see human beings used as one type of money, as a way of providing a measure of value. You paid in humans, or you paid yourself over to secure a debt.

You mean your labor?

Your labor, but also your whole body. You enter into the household of the person you owe and work it off.






Publicado originalmente en www.salon.com

   
 

Rating: 4 - 1 voto(s).

   
_COMENTARIOS
No existen comentarios.
Comentario / Comment:
  atención: para realizar comentarios tienes que ser usuario registrado.
        

_HistÓrico_Cultura

05-12-10_ After the hacking of UbuWeb * An open letter
01-11-08_ Todos los archivos del mundo...
28-03-09_ La libertad en Internet facilita el éxito de los artistas"
18-09-08_ Entrevista * Michel Montignag
08-06-08_ Para repudiar el nuevo Guggenheim (México)
22-05-08_ Inisde Landmark Forum
07-05-08_ ELÁSTICA VARIABLE * Imagen y Conocimiento
08-04-08_ Bajo el asfalto estaba la red
19-02-08_ La palabra [imagen] encendida [apagada]: on [off]
24-03-08_ Zemos 98... 99... 100...
24-03-08_ Arriba, abajo, de lado, tirado...
27-05-08_ Fuentes de la fragmentación e hipertextualidad narrativas en la web
09-12-07_ Schwarz auf Weib (negro sobre blanco): palabras en busca de un mundo
21-11-07_ UBU * Selected by Christof Migone
09-10-07_ Elogio del editor suicida
04-10-07_ Operación: Salvar el Reina Sofía (ohjú)
01-08-07_ Hans Rosling issues new challenges 
12-07-07_ PIENSA * De gestión y pensamiento
06-07-07_ Navegacion: las huellas borradas
29-06-07_ Hipertexto * El fluir del pensamiento.
29-06-07_ MARC FUMAROLI: "La cultura se ha convertido en una ensaladilla rusa, ¡en una pizzeria!
27-06-07_ De lo insabido que hace saber...
02-06-07_ The Black Dog
03-05-07_ Nico * Frozen borderline
31-05-07_ Alex Katz * Interview
29-03-07_ Otto von Busch * Abstrak Hacktivism
31-05-07_ Alain Badiou * Truth
12-03-07_ Interview * Anthony Dunne
03-03-07_ Kill your idols
12-02-07_  El teatro imposible 
03-02-07_ An Alliance of lions
28-01-07_  Maria Antonieta o, ¿el regreso del Posmodernismo?
28-01-07_ México, el vuelo del águila
22-01-07_ Open-of-Course
19-01-07_ Santi Santamaría (interjección)
09-01-07_ Una vivencia (-sueño) nocturna * Ludwig Wittgenstein
06-01-07_ UbuWeb Featured Resources Januray 2007 Selected by Mónica de la Torre
05-01-07_ Umberto Eco: ¿para qué sirven los diarios?
19-12-06_ Interview * Mark Shepard
13-12-06_ Contra Cage
02-12-06_ UbuWeb Featured Resources December 2006 Selected by Raphael Rubinstein
23-11-06_ Jonas Mekas 32 films
22-11-06_ Sundance Winner 'The Corporation' Released for Free on BitTorrent
14-11-06_Como nos vemos. Del Renacimiento a YouTube* Hubert Burda
01-11-06_Crónica de un fin de semana anunciado
30-10-06_El espejo acústico
01-11-06_Viernes 27 a tope: aviso a navegantes
22-10-06_Un mundo sin Copyright
16-10-06_Robert Anton Wilson: The I in the Triangle
08-10-06_ Yeah Yeah Yeahs in Australia
28-09-06_Miles Davis, Romantic Hero
24-09-06_Barbara Kruger and William Gibson * on information with Tim Marlow
19-09-06_ A bibliography of Things
20-09-06_Los vaivenes de la moda en el MOMA y la Tate Modern
14-09-06_Dubstep, el underground eterno
06-09-06_Experimenting with Brands in Second Life
03-09-06_Download Public Domain Books in PDF For Free
21-08-06_Últimos «gatillazos» de Taylor-Wood
17-08-06_Writing About Virtual Words
12-08-06_The Ghost In Your Genes
06-08-06_Guy Debord (1931-1994) * Films
03-08-06_perfiles, recomendaciones y feliz verano
01-08-06_Jugando con el tiempo: Will Wright y Brian Eno
28-07-06_Bukowski y la nostalgia
20-07-06_Enigma variations * Pierre Huyghe
30-06-06_It's a Wonderful List
22-06-06_la vida secreta de los libros
17-06-06_The death of the critic
18-06-06_Del pop-art al 'videoclip'
05-06-06_Marketing to avatars
05-06-06_Generation next
12-05-06_Los escándalos de negatividad
05-05-06_El garaje Hermético de Jerry Cornelius * Moebius
31-05-07_ Miles Davis, más alla
21-04-06_Siempre la misma
19-04-06_¡¡MADRID LEE!! (y otras pildoras de su interes)
08-04-06_100 años de Beckett * Déjenlos que se rían
29-03-06_Monkish
27-03-06_Adios, Stanislaw Lem
27-03-06_Don't Do Unto Others
25-03-06_Entrevista * Slavoj Zizek
19-03-06_Los Angeles, capital del arte del siglo XXI
19-03-06_El Objeto y La Música
12-03-06_Santayana-Lowell, cartas del viejo filósofo al joven poeta
01-03-06_Hoy he visto el futuro del rock y no se llama BS
01-03-06_Sobre la ciencia ficción
28-02-06_Tommy Lee Jones / Los tres entierros de Melquiades Estrada
28-02-06_Más moderna que ninguna
23-02-06_The fine art of revenge
18-02-06_From Russia With Blood / The horrors of Night Watch.
15-02-06_Un encuentro con Giorgio Agamben
12-02-06_Happy Birthday Charlie: Darwin Celebrated With Cake, Fossils
07-02-06_Arco: con un 'picasso' en el bolsillo
30-01-06_Araki, el pornógrafo compulsivo
29-01-06_Las líneas secretas de la escritura
25-01-06_Navahoax
27-01-06_When Cosmologies Collide
20-01-06_Darwin on Trial
17-01-06_My House, Bauhaus
16-01-06_Portrait of the Artist as a Young Artist
13-01-06_Copiátelo en la cabeza
13-01-06_Los seres humanos matamos más que la muerte
08-01-06_No usarás el nombre de la cultura en vano
09-01-06_Permanencias Difusas
24-11-07_ Miles Davis: The Cellar Door Sessions 1970
21-12-05_Acid Christmas
03-12-05_Primer > Yo mismo Yo [ delayed yo-yo reloaded ]
05-11-05_Entre mis recuerdos
27-10-05_Harold Pinter / “Sobrevivir es mi principal objetivo”
02-09-05_The subject of art
20-07-05_Impermeables a Shakespeare
04-07-05_2666

_ORBITAL_Cultura

_Servicios

test
Regístrate y disfruta de utilidades de administración y gestión de los contenidos de e-limbo*
Recibe las novedades en tu correo electronico.
El futuro está escrito en las estrellas... Horóscopo creado por J.G. Ballard y dedicado a todos vosotros.
Aplicaciones y herramientas necesarias para navegar y utilizar los contenidos del limbo electrónico e internet (www).
Artículos de e-limbo* en formato PDF preparados para viajar y aportar información allá donde estés. (y seguir salvando árboles)

_e-limbo * apoya

test

_Multimedia

_AUDIO >
Mais uma edição do podcast Música Livre para o Archivo Vivo, do Centro Cultural da Espanha/AECID. ...
_PODCAST >
Ante preguntas de oyentes y amigos, puedo responder ahora que Vía Límite continuará en Radio ...
_VIDEO >
SORPRESA¡!¡! An unreleased version of Talking Heads' "Psycho Killer" with Arthur Russell on cello
Optimizado: Firefox, Safari, Mozilla, Netscape, Konqueror, Explorer. Resolución óptima: 1024x768
ISSN: 1885-5229    Aviso Legal e-limbo.org*